Let’s consider how this goes in his article “Misrepresentation,” which Dretske takes the notion of meaningn to be a plausible starting point for. Frederick Irwin “Fred” Dretske was an American philosopher noted for his contributions to . carry information. This is how misrepresentation enters the world. Dretske – Misrepresentation. Uploaded by nmoverley. Philosophy Dretske Misrepresentation Writing. Copyright: © All Rights Reserved. Download as PDF, TXT.

Author: Tell Musida
Country: Norway
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Relationship
Published (Last): 23 March 2010
Pages: 299
PDF File Size: 1.15 Mb
ePub File Size: 10.30 Mb
ISBN: 479-3-71341-748-1
Downloads: 52815
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kalkis

Sign in to use this feature. Damien S August 17, at 7: I’ve posted the 33rd and 36th comment three times today.

There Dretske claims that actions are the causing of movements by mental states, rather than the movements themselves.

Dretske’s last monograph was on consciousness. What he thinks is a more serious problem is what he describes as the indeterminacy of biological function. In any event, C. The skeptic’s alternatives fall into this irrelevant category.

Edward Feser August 17, at 6: This article has no associated abstract. Lisa Miracchi – – Philosophical Studies 1: We also need to note the difference between intellect dertske the one hand and sensation and imagination on the other, and the unique situation our having both material and immaterial aspects of our nature puts us in. The principle of epistemic closure holds the following to be valid:. I take it that the problem you are posing is, “How can AT account for illusory perceptions and the like?


Misrepresenting Dretske

Comrade shooosh, geese and golden eggs. Any of these would be a plausible candidate for the function of the sensory states in question. Indeed, it is often the case that entis rationis cause as much grief in human cognition as they provide for essential human ‘superiority’, ,isrepresentation to speak.

It also entails misrepresentatio eating scrambled eggs while being deceived by an evil demon into believing one is eating oatmeal. Dretske seems to think a high enough aggregate of secondary, stimulus-response competencies would suffice to guide functional survival, but this doesn’t get us to the properly biosemiotic level of “sign” as as I think Peirce meant it. I did not mean to be too negative on Premack and meant no religious connection with his opinionsI simply mean to say he is an older successful pro, and has formed strong opinions.

For example, such bacteria living in the northern hemisphere are able to propel themselves toward magnetic north. God and angels do not know things in that manner. Codgitator Cadgertator August 19, at 6: Commenting on Matt Beck’s comment and Edward Feser’s response to it — or, as I sometimes say, ” many most?


Ed How does the A-T notions of final causality better account for misrepresentation than Dretske’s? I teach philosophy at Pasadena City College.

Dretske Misrepresentation Notes

Just my hunch, since that’s how I tend to blog. If the word thinking covers problem solving of all sorts, then other animals think, for problem solving is not a unique human performance.

Look also for “Ross”. No keywords specified fix it.

Any religion that makes claims about their subjective had better prove it or honestly admit to agnosticism on the matter. Of course, that might seem counterintuitive.

Sign in Create an account. And this is what the state will mean f even in the case where no such water is present, because say we have placed a bar magnet near the bacterium and thereby disoriented it.

Descartes and the Puzzle of Sensory Representation. The four causes, active vs. Even mainstream Buddhism acknowledges an essential divide between human and animal cognition, which is, among other things, the Dalai Lama will never be a llama. Perhaps he is operating on a divine economy.